12/2/2023 0 Comments 128 tuning fork medical![]() The 256-Hz tuning fork performed best, with a sensitivity of about 90%, but unfortunately, the test had very poor specificity: only around 20%. conducted an experiment similar to Lesho’s, but tested 256 Hz and 512 Hz tuning forks in addition to the 128 Hz fork used by Lesho. 3 Robert Wilder and colleagues at the University of Virginia studied forty-five distance runners with a suspected stress fracture. Misdiagnosis of Stress Fractures?Īnother study published in 2009 looked at the tuning fork test as well, but this time, in distance runners specifically. Lesho concluded that the tuning fork test was not sensitive enough to be able to rule out a stress fracture if there was no pain during the test, but he suggested that a positive tuning fork test might be enough to justify treating a patient for a stress fracture immediately instead of waiting for advanced imaging results. In Lesho’s study, the sensitivity and specificity of the tuning fork test were determined to be 75% and 67%, respectively-not too bad compared to a plain x-ray, but rather poor compared to the MRI’s 100% and 86%. If an abnormality does show up on an X-ray, the probability that you do have a stress fracture is 95%, meaning the test has high specificity. Sensitivity tells us how many true positives are correctly identified by a diagnostic test, and specificity likewise tells us how many true negatives are correctly identified as such.įor example, looking at plain X-rays to diagnose stress fractures has low sensitivity: according to one study, only about half of all stress fractures will show up on a regular X-ray. In evaluating a diagnostic test, there are two important parameters to measure: the sensitivity and specificity. Lesho employed both a tuning fork test, where a 128 Hz tuning fork was struck and held in direct contact with the painful spot on the shin, and a traditional bone scan, one of the gold standards for diagnosing stress fractures (the other being MRI). 1 His study examined fifty-two patients suspected of having a tibial stress fracture. The first was published in 1997 by Emil Patrick Lesho, a military doctor stationed at Fort Richardson in Arkansas. Two peer-reviewed scientific studies have been conducted on the efficacy of the “tuning fork test” for diagnosing a stress fracture. A tuning fork can be had for less than ten dollars, versus up to two thousand dollars for a single MRI scan. It seems like a reasonable proposition, and if it really works, the tuning fork would be a fantastic addition to any doctor or trainer’s inventory. When the tuning fork is struck, then held in contact with the bone, high-frequency vibrations travel into the bone, causing sharp pain if a stress fracture exists-or so the logic goes. One of the tools employed by old-school athletic trainers is the tuning fork. It’s used as an in-the-moment diagnostic tool to determine whether a runner has a stress fracture. These grizzled veterans of the turf field and the tartan track can have innumerous tricks up their sleeve, whether it’s curing foot pain with an expertly-placed pad of moleskin, easing a blister with a band-aid and a strip of tape, or modifying an ill-fitting shoe with a precise cut from a razor blade. Though trainers are often viewed as an initial point of contact for injury care with only rudimentary training, the best trainers can rival doctors in knowledge and experience. If you played a sport in high school or college, you probably had to see the athletic trainer at some point. In this article, we are going to look into how reliable it is to use a tuning fork to give you some peace of mind, without paying hundreds (or thousands) of dollars for a medical analysis. One of the methods that has been traditionally used to diagnose a stress fracture, without the costly MRI or Bone Scan is the tuning fork. Your mind starts to spin out of control as you search for a diagnosis, anything that will tell you what it is. When something hurts and you know in your heart that this is something serious, you hope and pray that it is not this, you know, the one that will put you in a boot for 6 weeks, immobilized.Īs runners we are very diligent, we do our homework….even if it means asking the one doctor we know we shouldn’t listen to Dr. There are two words that strike fear into any runner.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |